Cellar Cafe Fingal Bay

Had a late afternoon lunch here yesterday and loved everything about the whole place. The food was really delicious, loaded with lots of fresh herbs and ingredients. The decor and atmosphere was excellent, could see myself sitting here having a beverage and enjoying the atmosphere of an afternoon. There's an awesome back deck area that is tucked out of the way and great place to sit. The staff where really genuine and friendly. The amenities where clean and suitable for the area. I will be definitely returning here for a meal or beverage.

Parked out front, it was busy inside. Rang to order take away pizza, realised a man in his 30s ginger ish hair was taking my call, after saying what I wanted he asked me to hold, he walked to the back of the store out of sight, return to my vision moments later and I clearly seen him look at the landline he was holding and hang up as I hear the disconnect in my ear. I also could hear inside the shop as he mocked to his colleague about takeaway orders. So I went in pushing through the busy dining area to place an order with a lovely young girl. With an approximate 25 min wait return to my car to free up space. 20 mins later I hear MR NOT INTERESTED softly call my name. The pizza base is thin and super crunchy, nice but my 3 little pigs has roast beef, I'm serious, I guess the little pig went to market! The supreme is not very supreme, overall both pizzas are what I'd describe as " lite" and so little cheese, I honestly don't know if there was any at all🤔. I've now deconstructed it to find cheese, it's there but wafer thin and sporadically sprinkled and melted around.Overpriced but you pay for convenience of not having to go to Shoal Bay. Perhaps if you had a carafe or pint at the Cellar it would be acceptable.

Lovely food and service 🩷🩷🩷 we had the chicken burger which pleased my fussy daughter and the halloumi cheese bites my son said they were amazing.

First of all the pizza is amazing. Perfect thin crust that’s crispy but not dry. Secondly the staff are out of this world, so welcoming and friendly. Great wine and beer selection, really good prices . They have high chairs too 👍

The best salad we’ve had in the whole of Port Stephens! So delicious and reasonably priced. Friendly staff and option to have a cheeky pint whilst you wait for your takeaway.